Are too many political candidates campaigning in "the Cave"?

Is negative political advertising harmful or helpful in getting political candidates elected today?. This article examines some of the moral highground politicans give up if they sink too low in attacking their opponents. It uses Plato's Analogy of the Cave and suggests how voters can take an active roll in demanding more intelligent and civil messages from those seeking public office.

Socrates to Glaucon

Let me show you in an analogy how far our nature is enlightened or unenlightened. Behold politicians living in a cave, which has a mouth open toward the light. They have lived here from birth with their legs and necks chained so that they cannot move, and can only see the cave wall before them, being prevented by the chains from turning their heads. Most politicians are decent people who care about their country. But they are prisoners of that wall. To win elections they see shadows of their opponents on that wall and think they are seeing reality. The only opinions they hear are echoes of their own voices bouncing around the cave.

Glaucon:

Truly that explains why they say such ugly, distorted things about each other. I see by today's news scroll that the two Virginia Senatorial candidates are saying some good things but then, suddenly, they begin to mud wrestle with words. How can you throw mud without getting your own hands dirty?

Socrates:

And how else to explain how two honorable men with thoughtful ideas can waste time accusing each other of everything with meaningless "he said/he said" arguments - HE is delaying armaments for soldiers and not paying taxes on stock options, or counter charges - HE is demeaning women and a reflection of the lusty words he wrote in his novels. But Virginia candidates are not alone in spreading thinly-researched insults. Too many political candidates all over America mix campaigns with calumny - rumor and innuendoes. Let me speak plainly. Many people country are facing real problems - an unending war, lack of access to affordable health care, and dangers to their Social Security and pension plans. Political candidates have an obligation to address these problems with their own solutions. Of course, they have a right to speak forcefully to defend themselves when they are attacked with false words. But there is a narrow ethical line they must not cross. Instead of offering thoughtful ideas, too many debase their responses with their own overblown accusations - everything from charges that opponents choked their mistresses to making pornographic phone calls and accepting bribes and all other manner of civil and legal crimes.

Glaucon:

That is true. And so shameful for democracy. But many say these cruel words win elections. Socrates: My good citizen, remember last week I told you the cautionary "Tale of ENRON"? Sadly we have seen that lies and exaggerations can sometimes build great fortunes. But should we elect the most successful liars and exaggerators as our leaders?

Glaucon:

No! No! Certainly not! But how can concerned voters choose the right candidates?

Socrates:

Voters must break their own chains, turn their heads and look for the light at the opening of the cave. Who among these candidates for public trust are honestly trying to see both sides of complex issues? Who actually listens to what his or her opponent is saying and responds in a thoughtful honest debate.

But whenever citizens see or hear remarks from candidates that distort truth or spread hatred, they should send them a clear message: (Sir) or (Madam) I am a voter who loves this state and my country. I find your campaign full of "sound and fury, signifying nothing!"

Glaucon:

Good! And average people like me could post that message to candidates in our own emails and blogs. It could spread like a truth serum!

Socrates:

Glaucon, I am known as a Great Teacher, but sometimes I feel you are years ahead of me!

By Hal Gieseking, former consumer editor of Travel Holiday magazine and past president of the Society of American Travel Writers. Find more information about this editorial and a voter poll about the civility and intelligence of political advertising today at http://www.virginiahospitalitysuite.com.007 Films
Home In Key Vacation West
Clipart Download Free Microsoft
Cottages In Keswick
Lamp Post Globe
Real40
Flash Action Scripts
08 Cup Fifa Soccer World
Office Space Quote Milton
Incirlik Ab
1 Best Selling Book
Roulette Odds
100 Cascade Central Hike Hike Hundred In One Oregon
New York Crime
Career Choice Free Test
Ebay Toy Wwe
Hockey
Pennsville National Bank
Invention And Inventor
Manor Junior College
Jumbo Home Loans
China Growth Population Rate
1 2006 Holiday November
Unique Yoga Mat
1 Cart Ezgo Golf Tuff
Massage
Allerton Chicago Crowne Hotel Plaza
1 16 Farm Scale Toy
06 Fall Hair Style
Generator Myspace Page Web
Black Bike Fest
Real7
Agent Design Estate Real Site Web
Vending Product
Beach Comber Cove Crystal
Canadian Wholesale Distributor
Cub Cadet Lawn Mowers
Ticketing
Airline Attendant Flight Job Northwest
Murder Mystery
Pyrex Cooking
Grey Garden Review
Wholesale Logo T Shirt
06 Beach Bike Daytona Week
Toast 6 Titanium
Discount Golf Irons
Download Karaoke Purchase
Composite Video Switch
International Share Time Vacation
1000 Sea Star Tissot
O2 Network
Monterey Plaza Hotel And Spa
0 0interest Balance Card Credit Transfer
Football In League Little Spring Texas
19th Country Country England Inn Inn New Recommended Recommended Series
Septic Tank Yeast
Puerto Rico Beach Wedding
Shirt T Warcraft World
Dance Toronto Wear
Relationship Between Exotic Dancer And Customer
05 Fishing Tournament Walleye Wisconsin
007 James Bond Movies
National Geographic Magazine Web Site
The Eye Movie
100 Scene Snow
10 2007 California Obituary
Uk Property Rentals
07 2006 Almanac Farmer
Bahamas Nassau News
Magnetic Construction Toy
Nokia 3585
1 B Vitamin
Forest Friends Tree House
Bird Free House Pattern
0 Apr Business Card Credit Deal Instant
Health In Nutrition Philippine Public
Chocolate
Health Liver Supplement
B12 Food Vitamin
Government Loan Money Pay Student
Byetta Loss Pound Weight
0x800a0007 Windows Update Error
Entertainment Magazine News People
Drug Rehab In Malibu
Flag Garden Ohio State
1192 Pet Supply Wholesale
10 Best Forbes Live Magazine Place Top Work
Car Accident Lawyers New Haven
1 Dartmouth Furniture Gallery
1192 Pet Supply Wholesale
Nc Mountain Homesites
World
Restaurant New Milford Ct
1982 Obituary Roberts Ronald
Com Free Fun Game Play
B F Goodrich
Military Myspace Wallpaper
2008 Accord Coupe Honda Picture
Dialup Firewall
Real5
Scarecrow Costumes
1 2 Carat Diamond Earring Stud
Arkansas Football Schedule State
Call Center Chennai In Job
Real17
Contractor Electrical Licence
Crystal
Kids Global Warming
Beyonce Tickets
Prenatal Vitamin Online
San Jose Day Spa
Life27
Direct Multi Satellite System Tv
Pet Health Advice
Beloved Christ Jesus Picture
070185b Filter Generac Oil
Alternative Gasoline Fuel
Best Vacation Spot In The World
10 2005 Christmas Top Toy
Pa High School Football Score
06 Crystal Ice
Birth Dc Injury Lawyer Washington
0a Business Free From Home Opportunity Work
Personal Trainer
2 Cam Cam Chat Free
Dating A Non Christian
Apartment California Chino Rent
100 100 3rd Edition Hike Hike In Northwest Oregon Southwest Washington
1954 Ford Pickup Sale Truck
Apartment Chair Living Room Size Small
Bag
Quick Stop Oil Change
Dvd Firm Workout
Jewelry Tennis Bracelet
Ca Estate Listing Mls Real
Adult Princess Leia Costume
Fireman Wedding Cake Topper
Massage Therapist Orlando Fl
Drinking Driving Poem
Tiffany S Jewelry
2008 Bush Jeb Lose President
0 Advance Apr Cash
Condominium
Us Truck Driving School
2007 Architect Architect Construction Construction Contractor Contractor Cost Cost Engineer Engineer Guide Guide
Acne Complex Review
Finance Company Uk
National Wholesale Liquidators
Business School Schulich
Sectional Sofas With Chaise And Wedge Seats
100 Cotton Graphic T Shirt
Pilates For Dummy
K Cup Coffee
03 Springfield
Target Store New York
Bird Cage Large Uk
Online Belly Dance Video
07 Gmc New Truck
Internet Dating Tip
Recipe For Tortilla Crusted Tilapia
By Furniture Garden Plan Project Step Step Yard
0 Balance Transfer
Lamp Motion Vintage
Roller Tool Bag
Chuck Machine Norris Workout
In La Odor Pet Removal Services
Apartment Ca Francisco Rental San South
Wholesale Fendi Purse
Hair
Xbox Game Video Wholesale X
0 Car Financing
Jennifer Lopez Baby I Love You
Solar Powered Pond Pumps
Fragrance Making Oil Soap Supply
1967 Ford Part Truck
How To Learn To Do The Irish Dance
Hilton Garden Inn Sea World Orlando
04 Beach California Rental Vacation
Panama City Beach Condo Sales
Realestate
National Cost Of Living Index
Marketing Job Site
Dave Cook Mortgate Cookie
0 Apr Credit Card
Business School University York
Good Hair Kid Scene Style
Alvin Baseball College Community
Carpet Rc Car
Massage
California Pizza Kitchen Recipe
Decoration Idea Living Room
1982 Obituary Roberts Ronald
1 Ae Camera Canon
Chocolate Ice Cream Pie
Conception Site Web
1 Christmas Christmas Origami Origami Ornament Tree
Sea World
Medical Transcription Resume Sample
Twilight Zone Golden Earring Mp3
07 The Clairvoyant
Corporate Entertainment Party
Cartoon Valley Comic
Diecast Toy Tractor Trailer
Dress
Best Pork Recipe Roast
California Contractor License
Recipes
Free Cell Phone Ring Tone Nextel2fmotorola
Baby Christmas Pajamas
Recipes
New York High School Directory
Oil Make Your Own Perfume
Washington National Baseball Ticket
Baseball Boards Electronic Score
Gardening Magazine Organic
Oil Profit
Free Page White
Coconut Oil Tablespoon Virgin
1968 France Gall Music Shopping Track Yahoo
Mexico Soccer Usa
Christmas
10 90s Change Driving Force Future Managing
100 360 Xbox Sale X
College Football Handicapping Ncaa Sports
06 Xbox Cheat Madden X
Washington State Marriage Law
Lava Lamp Kid
Crm Customer Relationship Manage
10 Change Discover In Life Living Spiritual Steps Truth Zone
Sacramento Theatre
Burberry Cologne Touch
Bmw Jacket
Medical Insurance Billing And Coding An Essential Worktext
Blue Store
Life12
Ky Singles
Air Techniques Inc
Open Water 2
Myrtle Beach Time Share Tour
W New York Times Square Hotel
Home Kb Martha Stewart
Corner Entertainment Center Pocket Door
Tennis Master
10 Anxiety Anxiety Coping Fear Relieve Simple Ways Worry
In Office Sacramento Unemployment
04 Advice Dating
Crofts Ellen Machine Pilates Supreme
Latin Music Internet Radio
Civic Community Garden Grove Organization
Personals Dating Service
Carpet Coffee From Removing Stain
Auto Oil Leak Mat
In3
Washington Mutual Santa Barbara
Motel Inn
Peak Fitness Gym
30 Gig Ipod Refurbished
Waterloo Ice House
Business Directory Korean
Caffeine In Tea
0336 679 800 Number Phone
Best Gas Prices
Accessory Auto Cheap Part Toyota
Buy Canadian Stock
Ariat Boot On Sale
Adult Costumes Costume Rental
Batman The Beginning
Camping Coffee Maker
Bird Blue Rv Sale
Jimmy Osmond
Refurbished 60 Gb Ipod
Baseball College Junior Texas
Above Ground Pool Design
Black Table Lamp
Barton Creek Golf Package
Indoor Soccer Ball
Free National Phone Directory
Vegetarian Products
Little House On The Prairie Book
American Flag Desktop Wallpaper
Skincare
Adult Costume Santa Sexy
Wildlife Photography Career
Coffee Republic Franchise
Current Global Warming Issues
Driving Job Tennessee Truck
Centrum Vitamin Side Effects
Mesothelioma
04 Answer Interview Job Question
Professional Party Planner
Loss Medication Weight
Express Gram Money Payment
Costume Dog Pig
Niche
Assembly Of The Lord Jesus Christ
Download Msn Plus
Ftd Flower Delivery
Karaoke Bar Vallejo
0 Finance On New Cars
02 Mobiles
The Priest
Watering Bulb
National Bank Of Pakistan New York
1 Job Usa
Beto Exercise Fitness Zumba
House Painting Tool
Wholesale Dell Computer
Hanes Shirt
Cold Weather Survival
Picture Of Bill Gates House
Farming
Natural Pimples Remedy
Aaa Insurance Agent
Birthday Idea Party Toddler
Shopping Do Internet Portugal
Rock Center Cafe New York City
Biker Babs
Apartment Fireplace Pet Pool Search
Shoes
Vietnam Wall Memorial
Pottery Barn Rug Carpet
Real5
1 Hit Wonders
Company Health Insurance Plan United
Checked Shirt
U 4
Inn Ky Lexington Red Roof
Machine Milling Norman Van
San Antonio Texas Hotel And Motel
Morning Star Vegetarian Food
Christian Cool T Shirt
Best Projection Televisions
House Pic
Baby Earrings
Real29
Analog Computers
Port Mansfield Fishing
Canada Number Phone Reverse Search
Cafe Day Have Nice Richmond Va
07 Gmc New Truck
Trout Fishing Nc
007 Spy Software
Coffee Combination Espresso Maker
Passion Flower Tea
Free Golf Tip Online
Dc Snow Pants
Animal Coffee Tables
Milk Maid
007 Nightfire Cheats
Before Character Christmas Nightmare
Designer Fragrance Manufacturer Type
Dating Personals Single Woman
Xmas Java Games Nokia 3100
Counseling Foundation Health Mental
Accessory Bath Bird
Business Plan Retail Store Sample
Life39
Kitchen Remodeling Glencoe
Good Retirement Gift
Obesity Support
Charter Corporate Ny Yacht
German Town
Stackable Outdoor Chaise Lounges
Holiday Inn Heathrow Airport
Real33
Best Of Mtv Unplugged
Life8
Ford Ranger Bed Cover
Broker Rating Stock
Hotel Safe
Clipart Image Wedding
Easy Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe
Directory India Mumbai Phone
Nutcracker Ballet Costumes
0 Apr Business Card Credit Deal Instant
Dedicated Database Server
10w 11 12v Halogen Lamp Mr
1 16 Deere John Toy
Life5
Customer Relationship Management Non Profit
United States Gypsum Co
100 Construction Financing Loan
06 Tacoma
Brand M Machine Ms Vending
Maui Activities
10 Layer Chocolate Cake
0 3 Baby Costume Halloween Month
Acne Cyst Treatment
Che Guevera
Life2
Disney Hotel Property
Camera Motorola Mpx220 Pda Phone
Pur Ultimate Water Dispenser
Kenmore Carpet Cleaner
Flight
1 Portfolio Stock Yahoo
Network Nortel Quote Stock
2003 Crm Outlook
Curly Hair Photo Short
Evaluation Forex Training
California Championship Football High School State
Bean Coffee Vac
Funeral Gerald Levert Obituary
Costa Del Holiday Sol Villa
Plant And Flower Com
Reservation Southwest Vacation
Dress Gothic Plus Size Wedding
Stocks
Loss Story Success Teen Weight
Brick House Pizza
Life36
Detox Information
Democrat For 2008 Presidential
Glasses Guide And Directory
Earth Nz Quake Report
Food Customs Of Philippine
Chinese Karaoke Player
Backpack Bag Briefcase Laptop
Candy Chocolate Christmas Gift
Handbag Louis Vuitton Wallet
Lake Shore Hospital
06 Pro Tennis
Hotel Danieli Venice
Game Game Play Play Revised Series Toddler
Hanging Lamp Part
Designer Dog Collar And Leash
Wedding
Baby Doll Eden From Girl Precious Soft
Emergency Recovery Disk
0 60 Scion Tc
03 Affordable Dress Prom
Womens Tri Fitness
Farmer City Raceway
1 Bracelet Ct Diamond Tennis
Florida Fish And Game
Coral Sea Garden Resort
Marketing
Funny Cartoon Video Clip
Houston In Restaurant Texas
Personal Fashion Consultant
Agency Happy Holiday Travel
Washington International Soccer League
Www4
Breakfast Biscuit Recipe